AWS ELB vs HAProxy: Which Works Best For You

ELB vs HAProxyAWS’s Elastic Load Balancer (ELB) offers customers an easy way to handle load balancing for applications hosted on multiple Amazon EC2 instances. While using AWS ELB, there’s no need to worry about failover and availability – all that is managed by AWS. In this post, we’ll focus on some key features and then run a useful  AWS ELB vs HAProxy comparison.

Distributing and efficiently balancing incoming traffic is a basic and critical requirement for most web applications. Load balancers help to distribute and balance traffic based on different algorithms to filter for effects like round robin, session affinity, geographical location, and latency. Load balancers have been around for long enough that they’re part of a fully matured market. Both hardware and software balancers are widely available.

Still, while placing a load balancer in front of your application will definitely improve performance, it does carry some overhead, including setup and maintenance costs, and the need to ensure high availability and properly handle failure.

ELB vs HAProxy: ELB concepts

Load balancer types

In Amazon’s architectural design, a Virtual Private Cloud (VPC) is an isolated network into which you can launch compute resources. If you have Internet-facing instances in a public availability zone within a VPC, you would place an external load balancer on top of your resources to manage traffic. For devices inside a VPC’s private availability zone (for a corporate intranet, for example), you could deploy an internal load balancer.

SSL termination

ELB supports SSL termination at the load balancer itself, removing the need to manage SSL certificates at the application instance level. Flexible cipher support allows you to control the ciphers and protocols the load balancer presents to clients.

Sticky Sessions

Sticky sessions are central to the design of many web applications, and developers will usually need to write extra code to implement the feature. ELB can take over this task, allowing you to configure session stickiness in just a few steps…again, at the load balancer level.

Monitoring

Monitoring a load balancer can help you to identify all kinds of performance related issues related to metrics like request latency, request counts, and failed request counts. The data provided by Amazon CloudWatch can greatly simplify the monitoring process, leaving you free to concentrate on application development.

Logs

Using access logs to properly analyze web traffic or to diagnose application behavior is obviously very important. However, since AWS manages ELB – effectively keeping you away from the underlying hardware – you can’t get to your logs the way you normally would on servers that you manage directly. Enabling Access Logs and pointing to the S3 bucket where you’d like your logs stored will cause all relevant log data to be transferred to S3. From there, you’ll be able to analyze away to your heart’s content.

Health Checks

Before a load balancer can redirect requests to a server, it’s important to determine the availability (or health) of the underlying server/application. By pointing your balancer’s health check to a custom application endpoint, its status will be regularly monitored. Health checks will then try to ping, say, your index.html page. If it receives a “200” response code, then it will assume everything is fine. “400” responses would mean there’s trouble, and traffic could be routed away from that server.

ELB vs HAProxy

There may be times when you won’t want to use a load balancer provided by AWS. For instance,

  • You may prefer an open source solution.
  • You may wish to avoid vendor lock in.
  • You don’t want to give up control over load balancer management and security.

For such scenarios you should be able to intelligently compare ELB vs HAProxy, a widely-adopted open source (software-based) load balancer. Besides being fairly simple to configure, here are some of the things that HAProxy does well:

  • When comparing ELB vs HAProxy, the former can feel a bit limited as far as load balancing algorithms are concerned. It supports only round robin and session stickiness. But consider cases where you need to load the balancer based on incoming URL, or on the number of connections to be handled by individual underlying severs. HAProxy can handle those, and more.
  • An Elastic Load Balancer can’t be associated with a static IP address – or even a range of IPs. It can therefore be difficult to create a whitelist to filter traffic coming through an ELB balancer. On the other hand, you could always set up HAProxy on an EC2 instance and assign an Elastic IP address to that instance. That IP can then easily be used in your firewall to whitelist requests.
  • Pricing may or may not be a big deal for you, but it can’t hurt to bring it up. AWS charges you for each hour or partial hour that your Elastic Load Balancer is running, and for each GB of data transferred through your Elastic Load Balancer. Since HAProxy is open source, on the other hand, setting it up and running it on an EC2 instance will cost you nothing more than the normal instance usage.

You definitely shouldn’t think I’ve got anything against AWS ELB. In fact, they’re constantly improving their product. Rather, I’ve simply tried to present various scenarios that can have more than one possible solution. It’s up to you to compare ELB vs HAProxy (along with other options) and choose whatever will work best for you.

Therefore, if your business doesn’t require complex load balancing algorithms, and is fine with simple round robin patters then I would recommend ELB for its simplicity. Similarly, if your applications are deployed across different availability zones within an AWS region and the servers are running as part of an auto scaling group, then it will be much easier to seamlessly integrate your AWS resources if you use ELB.

Trying to get the same just done with HAProxy might not be quite so simple.

This post was intended to help you understand some key ELB features and, at the same time, introduce you to an important open source load balancer solution (HAProxy). The rest is up to you.

If you’d like to add your own thoughts on the ELB vs HAProxy conversation, please leave a comment.

If you want to get a jump start on ELB, check out Cloud Academy’s Introduction to ELB course.

Avatar

Written by

Vineet Badola

Working as a cloud professional for last 6 years in various organizations, I have experience in three of the most popular cloud platforms, AWS IaaS, Microsoft Azure and Pivotal Cloud Foundry PaaS platform. Having around 10 years of IT experience in various roles and I take great interest in learning and sharing my knowledge on newer technologies. Wore many hats as developer, lead, architect in cloud technologies implementation. During Leisure time I enjoy good soothing music, playing TT and sweating out in Gym. I believe sharing knowledge is my way to make this world a better place.


Related Posts

Amanda Cross
Amanda Cross
— April 9, 2021

New Content: Platforms, Programming, and DevOps – Something for Everyone

This month our team of expert certification specialists released three new or updated learning paths, 16 courses, 13 hands-on labs, and four lab challenges! New content on Cloud Academy You can always visit our Content Roadmap to see what’s just released as well as what’s coming soon....

Read more
  • alibaba
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • DevOps
  • Google Cloud Platform
  • programming
  • Security
Luca Casartelli
Luca Casartelli
— March 31, 2021

Mastering AWS Organizations Service Control Policies

Service Control Policies (SCPs) are IAM-like policies to manage permissions in AWS Organizations. SCPs restrict the actions allowed for accounts within the organization making each one of them compliant with your guidelines. SCPs are not meant to grant permissions; you should consider ...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Organizations
  • SCP
Amanda Cross
Amanda Cross
— March 12, 2021

New Content: Focus on DevOps and Programming Content this Month

This month our team of expert certification specialists released 12 new or updated learning paths, 15 courses, 25 hands-on labs, and four lab challenges! New content on Cloud Academy You can always visit our Content Roadmap to see what’s just released as well as what’s coming soon. Ja...

Read more
  • alibaba
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • DevOps
  • Google Cloud Platform
  • programming
Amanda Cross
Amanda Cross
— February 12, 2021

New Content: Get Ready for the CISM Cert Exam & Learn About Alibaba, Plus All the AWS, GCP, and Azure Courses You Know You Can Count On

This month our team of intrepid certification specialists released five learning paths, seven courses, 19 hands-on labs, and three lab challenges!  One particularly interesting new learning path is Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) Foundations. After completing this learn...

Read more
  • alibaba
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • cism
  • DevOps
  • Google Cloud Platform
  • programming
Avatar
Cloud Academy Team
— January 31, 2021

Which Certifications Should I Get?

The old AWS slogan, “Cloud is the new normal” is indeed a reality today. Really, cloud has been the new normal for a while now and getting credentials has become an increasingly effective way to quickly showcase your abilities to recruiters and companies. With all that in mind, the s...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • Certifications
  • Cloud Computing
  • Google Cloud Platform
Avatar
Andrew Larkin
— January 31, 2021

The 12 AWS Certifications: Which is Right for You and Your Team?

As companies increasingly shift workloads to the public cloud, cloud computing has moved from a nice-to-have to a core competency in the enterprise. This shift requires a new set of skills to design, deploy, and manage applications in cloud computing. As the market leader and most ma...

Read more
  • AWS
  • AWS Certifications
Avatar
Stuart Scott
— January 29, 2021

AWS Certified Solutions Architect Associate: A Study Guide

Want to take a really impactful step in your technical career? Explore the AWS Solutions Architect Associate certificate. Its new version (SAA-C02) was released on March 23, 2020. The AWS Solutions Architect - Associate Certification (or Sol Arch Associate for short) offers some ...

Read more
  • AWS
  • AWS Certifications
  • AWS Certified Solutions Architect Associate
Amanda Cross
Amanda Cross
— January 7, 2021

New Content: AWS Terraform, Java Programming Lab Challenges, Azure DP-900 & DP-300 Certification Exam Prep, Plus Plenty More Amazon, Google, Microsoft, and Big Data Courses

This month our Content Team continues building the catalog of courses for everyone learning about AWS, GCP, and Microsoft Azure. In addition, this month’s updates include several Java programming lab challenges and a couple of courses on big data. In total, we released five new learning...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • DevOps
  • Google Cloud Platform
  • Machine Learning
  • programming
Avatar
Stuart Scott
— December 17, 2020

Where Should You Be Focusing Your AWS Security Efforts?

Another day, another re:Invent session! This time I listened to Stephen Schmidt’s session, “AWS Security: Where we've been, where we're going.” Amongst covering the highlights of AWS security during 2020, a number of newly added AWS features/services were discussed, including: AWS Audit...

Read more
  • AWS
  • AWS re:Invent
  • cloud security
Joe Nemer
Joe Nemer
— December 4, 2020

AWS re:Invent: 2020 Keynote Top Highlights and More

We’ve gotten through the first five days of the special all-virtual 2020 edition of AWS re:Invent. It’s always a really exciting time for practitioners in the field to see what features and services AWS has cooked up for the year ahead.  This year’s conference is a marathon and not a...

Read more
  • AWS
  • AWS Glue Elastic Views
  • AWS re:Invent
Bryony Harrower
Bryony Harrower
— November 6, 2020

WARNING: Great Cloud Content Ahead

At Cloud Academy, content is at the heart of what we do. We work with the world’s leading cloud and operations teams to develop video courses and learning paths that accelerate teams and drive digital transformation. First and foremost, we listen to our customers’ needs and we stay ahea...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • content roadmap
  • GCP
Joe Nemer
Joe Nemer
— October 25, 2020

Excelling in AWS, Azure, and Beyond – How Danut Prisacaru Prepares for the Future

Meet Danut Prisacaru. Danut has been a Software Architect for the past 10 years and has been involved in Software Engineering for 30 years. He’s passionate about software and learning, and jokes that coding is basically the only thing he can do well (!). We think his enthusiasm shines t...

Read more
  • AWS
  • careers
  • champions
  • upskilling