AWS ELB vs HAProxy: Which Works Best For You

ELB vs HAProxyAWS’s Elastic Load Balancer (ELB) offers customers an easy way to handle load balancing for applications hosted on multiple Amazon EC2 instances. While using AWS ELB, there’s no need to worry about failover and availability – all that is managed by AWS. In this post, we’ll focus on some key features and then run a useful  AWS ELB vs HAProxy comparison.

Distributing and efficiently balancing incoming traffic is a basic and critical requirement for most web applications. Load balancers help to distribute and balance traffic based on different algorithms to filter for effects like round robin, session affinity, geographical location, and latency. Load balancers have been around for long enough that they’re part of a fully matured market. Both hardware and software balancers are widely available.

Still, while placing a load balancer in front of your application will definitely improve performance, it does carry some overhead, including setup and maintenance costs, and the need to ensure high availability and properly handle failure.

ELB vs HAProxy: ELB concepts

Load balancer types

In Amazon’s architectural design, a Virtual Private Cloud (VPC) is an isolated network into which you can launch compute resources. If you have Internet-facing instances in a public availability zone within a VPC, you would place an external load balancer on top of your resources to manage traffic. For devices inside a VPC’s private availability zone (for a corporate intranet, for example), you could deploy an internal load balancer.

SSL termination

ELB supports SSL termination at the load balancer itself, removing the need to manage SSL certificates at the application instance level. Flexible cipher support allows you to control the ciphers and protocols the load balancer presents to clients.

Sticky Sessions

Sticky sessions are central to the design of many web applications, and developers will usually need to write extra code to implement the feature. ELB can take over this task, allowing you to configure session stickiness in just a few steps…again, at the load balancer level.

Monitoring

Monitoring a load balancer can help you to identify all kinds of performance related issues related to metrics like request latency, request counts, and failed request counts. The data provided by Amazon CloudWatch can greatly simplify the monitoring process, leaving you free to concentrate on application development.

Logs

Using access logs to properly analyze web traffic or to diagnose application behavior is obviously very important. However, since AWS manages ELB – effectively keeping you away from the underlying hardware – you can’t get to your logs the way you normally would on servers that you manage directly. Enabling Access Logs and pointing to the S3 bucket where you’d like your logs stored will cause all relevant log data to be transferred to S3. From there, you’ll be able to analyze away to your heart’s content.

Health Checks

Before a load balancer can redirect requests to a server, it’s important to determine the availability (or health) of the underlying server/application. By pointing your balancer’s health check to a custom application endpoint, its status will be regularly monitored. Health checks will then try to ping, say, your index.html page. If it receives a “200” response code, then it will assume everything is fine. “400” responses would mean there’s trouble, and traffic could be routed away from that server.

ELB vs HAProxy

There may be times when you won’t want to use a load balancer provided by AWS. For instance,

  • You may prefer an open source solution.
  • You may wish to avoid vendor lock in.
  • You don’t want to give up control over load balancer management and security.

For such scenarios you should be able to intelligently compare ELB vs HAProxy, a widely-adopted open source (software-based) load balancer. Besides being fairly simple to configure, here are some of the things that HAProxy does well:

  • When comparing ELB vs HAProxy, the former can feel a bit limited as far as load balancing algorithms are concerned. It supports only round robin and session stickiness. But consider cases where you need to load the balancer based on incoming URL, or on the number of connections to be handled by individual underlying severs. HAProxy can handle those, and more.
  • An Elastic Load Balancer can’t be associated with a static IP address – or even a range of IPs. It can therefore be difficult to create a whitelist to filter traffic coming through an ELB balancer. On the other hand, you could always set up HAProxy on an EC2 instance and assign an Elastic IP address to that instance. That IP can then easily be used in your firewall to whitelist requests.
  • Pricing may or may not be a big deal for you, but it can’t hurt to bring it up. AWS charges you for each hour or partial hour that your Elastic Load Balancer is running, and for each GB of data transferred through your Elastic Load Balancer. Since HAProxy is open source, on the other hand, setting it up and running it on an EC2 instance will cost you nothing more than the normal instance usage.

You definitely shouldn’t think I’ve got anything against AWS ELB. In fact, they’re constantly improving their product. Rather, I’ve simply tried to present various scenarios that can have more than one possible solution. It’s up to you to compare ELB vs HAProxy (along with other options) and choose whatever will work best for you.

Therefore, if your business doesn’t require complex load balancing algorithms, and is fine with simple round robin patters then I would recommend ELB for its simplicity. Similarly, if your applications are deployed across different availability zones within an AWS region and the servers are running as part of an auto scaling group, then it will be much easier to seamlessly integrate your AWS resources if you use ELB.

Trying to get the same just done with HAProxy might not be quite so simple.

This post was intended to help you understand some key ELB features and, at the same time, introduce you to an important open source load balancer solution (HAProxy). The rest is up to you.

If you’d like to add your own thoughts on the ELB vs HAProxy conversation, please leave a comment.

If you want to get a jump start on ELB, check out Cloud Academy’s Introduction to ELB course.

Avatar

Written by

Vineet Badola

Working as a cloud professional for last 6 years in various organizations, I have experience in three of the most popular cloud platforms, AWS IaaS, Microsoft Azure and Pivotal Cloud Foundry PaaS platform. Having around 10 years of IT experience in various roles and I take great interest in learning and sharing my knowledge on newer technologies. Wore many hats as developer, lead, architect in cloud technologies implementation. During Leisure time I enjoy good soothing music, playing TT and sweating out in Gym. I believe sharing knowledge is my way to make this world a better place.

Related Posts

Avatar
Michael Sheehy
— August 19, 2019

What Exactly Is a Cloud Architect and How Do You Become One?

One of the buzzwords surrounding the cloud that I'm sure you've heard is "Cloud Architect." In this article, I will outline my understanding of what a cloud architect does and I'll analyze the skills and certifications necessary to become one. I will also list some of the types of jobs ...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Cloud Computing
Avatar
Andrew Larkin
— August 13, 2019

Content Roadmap: AZ-500, ITIL 4, MS-100, Google Cloud Associate Engineer, and More

Last month, Cloud Academy joined forces with QA, the UK’s largest B2B skills provider, and it put us in an excellent position to solve a massive skills gap problem. As a result of this collaboration, you will see our training library grow with additions from QA’s massive catalog of 500+...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • content roadmap
  • Google Cloud Platform
Avatar
Adam Hawkins
— August 9, 2019

DevSecOps: How to Secure DevOps Environments

Security has been a friction point when discussing DevOps. This stems from the assumption that DevOps teams move too fast to handle security concerns. This makes sense if Information Security (InfoSec) is separate from the DevOps value stream, or if development velocity exceeds the band...

Read more
  • AWS
  • cloud security
  • DevOps
  • DevSecOps
  • Security
Avatar
Stefano Giacone
— August 8, 2019

Test Your Cloud Knowledge on AWS, Azure, or Google Cloud Platform

Cloud skills are in demand | In today's digital era, employers are constantly seeking skilled professionals with working knowledge of AWS, Azure, and Google Cloud Platform. According to the 2019 Trends in Cloud Transformation report by 451 Research: Business and IT transformations re...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Cloud skills
  • Google Cloud
  • Microsoft Azure
Avatar
Andrew Larkin
— August 7, 2019

Disadvantages of Cloud Computing

If you want to deliver digital services of any kind, you’ll need to estimate all types of resources, not the least of which are CPU, memory, storage, and network connectivity. Which resources you choose for your delivery —  cloud-based or local — is up to you. But you’ll definitely want...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • Cloud Computing
  • Google Cloud Platform
Joe Nemer
Joe Nemer
— August 6, 2019

Google Cloud vs AWS: A Comparison (or can they be compared?)

The "Google Cloud vs AWS" argument used to be a common discussion among our members, but is this still really a thing? You may already know that there are three major players in the public cloud platforms arena: Amazon Web Services (AWS), Microsoft Azure, and Google Cloud Platform (GCP)...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Google Cloud Platform
  • Kubernetes
Avatar
Stuart Scott
— July 29, 2019

Deployment Orchestration with AWS Elastic Beanstalk

If you're responsible for the development and deployment of web applications within your AWS environment for your organization, then it's likely you've heard of AWS Elastic Beanstalk. If you are new to this service, or simply need to know a bit more about the service and the benefits th...

Read more
  • AWS
  • elastic beanstalk
Avatar
Stuart Scott
— July 26, 2019

How to Use & Install the AWS CLI

What is the AWS CLI? | The AWS Command Line Interface (CLI) is for managing your AWS services from a terminal session on your own client, allowing you to control and configure multiple AWS services and implement a level of automation. If you’ve been using AWS for some time and feel...

Read more
  • AWS
  • AWS CLI
  • Command line interface
Alisha Reyes
Alisha Reyes
— July 22, 2019

Cloud Academy’s Blog Digest: July 2019

July has been a very exciting month for us at Cloud Academy. On July 10, we officially joined forces with QA, the UK’s largest B2B skills provider (read the announcement). Over the coming weeks, you will see additions from QA’s massive catalog of 500+ certification courses and 1500+ ins...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Azure
  • Cloud Academy
  • Cybersecurity
  • DevOps
  • Kubernetes
Avatar
Stuart Scott
— July 18, 2019

AWS Fundamentals: Understanding Compute, Storage, Database, Networking & Security

If you are just starting out on your journey toward mastering AWS cloud computing, then your first stop should be to understand the AWS fundamentals. This will enable you to get a solid foundation to then expand your knowledge across the entire AWS service catalog.   It can be both d...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Compute
  • Database
  • fundamentals
  • networking
  • Security
  • Storage
Avatar
Adam Hawkins
— July 17, 2019

How to Become a DevOps Engineer

The DevOps Handbook introduces DevOps as a framework for improving the process for converting a business hypothesis into a technology-enabled service that delivers value to the customer. This process is called the value stream. Accelerate finds that applying DevOps principles of flow, f...

Read more
  • AWS
  • AWS Certifications
  • DevOps
  • DevOps Foundation Certification
  • Engineer
  • Kubernetes
Avatar
Vineet Badola
— July 15, 2019

AWS AMI Virtualization Types: HVM vs PV (Paravirtual VS Hardware VM)

Amazon Machine Images (AWS AMI) offers two types of virtualization: Paravirtual (PV) and Hardware Virtual Machine (HVM). Each solution offers its own advantages. When we’re using AWS, it’s easy for someone — almost without thinking —  to choose which AMI flavor seems best when spinning...

Read more
  • AWS
  • Hardware Virtual Machine
  • Paravirtual
  • Virtualization